fuzzybluemonkeys: fuzzy blue monkey (dean)
fuzzybluemonkeys ([personal profile] fuzzybluemonkeys) wrote2007-05-04 10:23 am
Entry tags:

It's just bugging me, is all

I don't like the way they cut the Dean Talks To The Grave Of Still-Dead Papa Winchester scene last night.
I mean, we know from the phone scene in Home that Jensen can rock the hell out of one-sided conversations with an inanimate objects in lieu of his fictional father, so why did they feel the need to hack this scene to bits?
They've got this totally poignant and meaningful scene where Dean talks to his dead father and realizes his purpose that would have had crazy impact as a straight uncut emotional whammy, but instead we get shots of Dean talking cut with shots of him not talking, and the audio continues talking even through the not talking shots to the point where I'm all, "Wait, have we switched to voiceover now? No, his lips are moving properly again. What the hell are they doing?"


Still the cutest lawn-mowing ever, though.

[identity profile] tobimonkee.livejournal.com 2007-05-05 01:39 am (UTC)(link)
and i was so busy noticeing the light and reflections of the cemtary i missed that
gigglingkat: sing for the laughter, sing for the tears (Default)

[personal profile] gigglingkat 2007-05-08 11:35 am (UTC)(link)
I went back and watched. It's definitely ADR work. Something tells me the script was originally very different, longer, or out of sequence to what we heard. I'm guessing it had to be redubbed for time and they didn't have the schedule for a reshoot...