Okay, so this has been bugging the crap out of me.

[fuzzybluemonkeys]

Let me see if I understand your insane troll logic here: Sam's soul is being horrifyingly tortured in Hell, therefore we should leave it in Hell, so that it can CONTINUE TO BE TORTURED.
What. The. Fuck.
In what alternate reality does that make anything even remotely resembling sense?

And then there's Samuel's crazypants: Yes, let's resurrect someone against their will. BECAUSE THAT ALWAYS TURNS OUT SO WELL.